Reflection in the Dark: When Prompt Optimization Forgets to Think
A prompt fails. The optimizer reflects. The prompt changes. The score moves. This is the part where everyone is supposed to feel comforted. A self-improving system has looked at its mistake and revised itself. Very modern. Very agentic. Very convenient. The less comforting possibility is that the system has not understood the mistake at all. It has simply rewritten the prompt around the nearest explanation it can imagine. The score may improve, stagnate, or fall, but the optimizer still cannot answer the most basic operational question: what exactly did we just fix? ...