When False Is the Wrong Answer Twice
TL;DR for operators Five patients receive drug A. Three improve, and two do not. Should an AI verifier label both “The patients improved” and “The patients didn’t improve” as False? Under the group-statement semantics tested in HomogeneityNLI, both are Neither—neither true nor false. Yet “Not all the patients improved” is True. The evidence is complete; the difference lies in what each statement means when outcomes are mixed. ...