An 8/10 Is Not a Probability: Validating LLM Confidence Before It Controls Workflow
TL;DR for operators A model saying “8/10 confident” does not mean its underlying uncertainty is approximately 20%. Across the evaluated settings, the average instance-level correlation between reported confidence and logits-based confidence is only 0.135. The more useful operating rule is narrower. First test whether reported scores vary enough to distinguish cases. Then measure whether those scores rank examples meaningfully on held-out data. Separately test whether their numerical scale agrees with the comparison signal and whether they are calibrated against correctness. Do not substitute one test for another. ...