When AI Becomes the Reviewer: Pairwise Judgment at Scale
Opening — Why this matters now Large scientific user facilities run on scarcity. Beam time, telescope hours, clean-room slots—there are never enough to go around. Every cycle, hundreds of proposals compete for a fixed, immovable resource. The uncomfortable truth is that proposal selection is not about identifying absolute excellence; it is about ranking relative merit under pressure, time constraints, and human fatigue. ...