Who’s Really in Charge? Epistemic Control After the Age of the Black Box
Control is a comforting word. It suggests a hand on the wheel, a dashboard of indicators, and a human being somewhere nearby who can still say no. Machine learning makes that picture look increasingly theatrical. In AI-assisted science, researchers often do not know exactly which internal representations a model has learned, why a high-dimensional classifier separates one tumor subtype from another, or whether a model’s “useful pattern” corresponds to anything a scientist would recognize as a meaningful mechanism. The black box does not merely sit inside the laboratory. It starts to participate in deciding what the laboratory can see. ...